Thursday, June 4, 2009

The Bubble

These are some of Jesus' words on the challenge of being a light in the darkness, which he prayed to his Father for us in anticipation of the problems his streetlights would face:


"I have given them your word and the world has hated them, for they are not of the world any more than I am of the world. My prayer is not that you take them out of the world but that you protect them from the evil one. They are not of the world, even as I am not of it. Sanctify them by the truth; your word is truth. As you sent me into the world, I have sent them into the world." (John 17:14-18)


Have you ever noticed how Christians have their own little set of catchphrases that we throw around like so many theological frisbees? You know, those little buzzwords that we've used so much that we don't even quite think about their meaning anymore but just assume that other Christians will understand? The ones that make people who aren't Christians go "I'm sorry, what now?" Well, This passage is probably the origin of the Christianese saying that we should be "in the world, but not of it."

But, before I go any further, I henceforth move that people who are trying to be streetlights avoid speaking Christianese at all costs, because of two main problems with it:

1.) It makes non-Christians, the very people we want to serve, love and share truth with the most, think we're crazy and want nothing to do with us and our elitist lingo.

2.) These trite little sayings dramatically minimize the true power and worth of the Bible, and also of our calling. This passage is a prime example of that.

Take a look at it: our little catch phrase version of this passage can only tell us that we find ourselves in this place that we don't really belong, so we should live here without letting the sins and customs of the world stain us and hinder our purposes. Not only does this shallowness not even begin to cover the heart of the passage, it also perpetuates what is probably the single biggest shortcoming of the Christian church today, a phenomenon I like to call the Christian Bubble.

This bubble mentality comes, as far as I can tell, from a line of thinking something like this: Well, we aren't supposed to be of the world, but we can't get out of it. So, maybe the best way to do that is to insulate ourselves from it. We'll form a protective shell around ourselves made out of catchphrases and exclusively "Christian" products so that no one else can relate to us. That way, we can interact only with other Christians and not be somehow tainted by the affairs of the world.

As my sarcasm should surely indicate, I think this way of living is ridiculous and completely unscriptural (although, unfortunately, all too easy to fall into). Look again and see what the scripture above actually says for us to do. Jesus could easily have prayed for God to actually take Christians out of the world, but he specifically did NOT do that. He wants us here. Why? Because of the message of good news we're supposed to be bringing (which it says two verses later than where I stopped quoting in that passage above).

Further, who is supposed to be protecting us from the world? Not us, with our walls and insulatory bubble. Jesus prays that God the Father would do the protecting! Why fear being tainted? If we go with the right heart, the protection is already provided. I don't know exactly why Christians treat people who don't believe in Jesus like they're carrying some kind of deadly contagion, but it has to stop. How can we love people if we're afraid of them?

Speaking of love, how does that passage say that we are sent? Exactly like the Father sent Jesus! First off, that's really encouraging, that we're privileged to share his message. But, it's also quite the challenge, because how did Jesus relate with the world? If you're thinking he loved it and served it, you're right because Jesus loved to get in the middle of people's lives with his radical kindness and relate to them right where they were. Still, that doesn't quite cover it. To really be sent into the world like Jesus was, as this verse commands, means we lay down our lives for it in order to bring people to God. Jesus was completely spent on this mission, and that is our call as well. Sounds a little different than just "in, not of," no?

Side tangent: Unfortunately what the Christian community has been doing instead of spending itself in love and pursuit of the people God calls them to reach is insulating itself. Heaven forbid that we listen to and like the same music as people "of the world." Why do that when we can make a lower quality, dumbed down version of the same product and then market it only to ourselves, since there's so many of us? And why stop at music! We can do this with movies, books, toys, t-shirts, etc. etc.... the possibilities are endless. Why would we need to be conversant with the mainstream culture that is all people we need to love will know?

Funny thing about that way of thinking and marketing is, it takes the world's stuff, then modifies it (usually making it worse) and takes it away to its own little protected zone. That's being of the world, but not in it, the exact opposite of what the strategy is supposed to be doing!

This is the Christian Bubble. And as it relates to Cleveland specifically, its line of thinking continues by saying, "why live in the city where the actual problems are, when we can settle in the suburbs and fence ourselves into a gated community?" See how the insulation works? Now, I'm not saying everyone has to live within the city limits to serve God, just that suburbia provides a perfect layer of insulation from the world for people looking for one. In reality, the suburbs have plenty of problems that Christians living there could address too if they were living like Jesus sent them to live. I mean, where do you think city drug dealers make their biggest sales? (If you don't know, the answer is to rich kids from the suburbs.) The suburbs just hide their problems better.

Anyway, all of that was kind of an extended sidebar to the main point. I don't mean to be a downer, even though I am a touch cynical and angry about all this. The truth is, Jesus has promised us the most fulfilling life imaginable in taking his message to the world, not in avoiding it.

Incidentally, that's the reason I like Stavesacre, my favorite band in the world (http://www.stavesacre.com/). All the members of the band are Christians, but they rebel against the Christian bubble and take their music to secular locations and just rock it out. They make a quality product that offends some Christians, but they don't seem to care. They're calling people to more than the bubble. Their song "It's Beautiful Once You're Out Here" (video available on Youtube) is about this, as is another older song, "Sundown Motel." I'll quote from that one to finish off this entry:

I don't believe this is what God ever intended, so I think it's time to go... The sun is going down, I say we follow it out of town, We've been here for far too long... and in the morning, when it rises, maybe it will shine for us...


Turns out that the call of the streetlight is for Christians and non-Christians alike: "Wake up, O sleeper, rise from the dead, and Christ will shine on you." I mean, a streetlight, by definition, brings light where? Not in some little protective covering placed around it, but in the streets.

We've been in a bubble far too long. But some of us are starting to break out...

3 comments:

Sarah said...

Hm. I agree with your points. I think however, that we even put too much effort in "breaking OUT" of the Christian bubble when really, God is calling us OUT of the mainstream all together. That includes "Christian industry" mainstream AND "secular industry" mainstream. Its this whole heart of humility and of meekness - strength under submission.

For me - a streetlight doesn't scream "HEY! I'M A FREAKING STREETLIGHT, HELLO!!!" For me its - one right after another. I don't think A streetlight, I think a BUNCH of them. And then I notice when the streetlight stops - because all of a sudden its an absense of light.

I don't know. I don't feel like I'm missing out on mainstream stuff either christian or either. I definitely believe God's heart is for the outsiders and the outcasts - people you never see. And that hey! if you where a christian shirt, great. HEY. If you listen to a secular band - whatever. But either way - to be in the world but not OF it means that we're in GODStream - and usually it goes against BOTH Christian and Secular mainstream alike. Thoughtful blog!

Sarah said...

arg. other* not either and wear* not where. *annoyed with obvious typo errors* hehe.

Ben said...

Good points, Sarah!

I hope it didn't seem like I was suggesting the secular media as the appropriate alternative to the Christian bubble... (although I do think maybe you can learn more about how to relate to and reach out to a non-Christian from the average Linkin Park song than you can from, say, the average MercyMe or Point of Grace song)...

I guess I just take it for granted that the secular media is messed up and that's why Christians could do much better than imitating it, especially in such polarizing and ineffective ways. I definitely agree that neither mainstream is the way to go. That's how we shine anyway: if we're the same as whatever's around us, be it secular or Christian, no one will see any light. But if we're really different, there won't be any need for us to say so :)

Calvin & Hobbes comic of the day